Worst Transfer Window Signings

Joined
Jan 9, 2009
Messages
128
Interesting article from the Daily Telegraph newspaper listing the top 25 worst transfer window singings (in reverse order). I have added the player's race.

The 25 worst buys in January transfer sales

By Martin Smith
30 Jan 2008

25. Calum Davenport Tottenham to West Ham - undisclosed 2007. Lightweight defender who could not make an impact in heavyweight relegation fight.
ENGLISH

24. Yaniv Katan Maccabi Haifa to West Ham - £100,000 2006. The Israeli signed a four-year deal for West Ham but this was reduced to six months and six games.
IRAQI JEW

23. Lee Bowyer Leeds to West Ham - £100,000 2003. Looked awkward, overawed and spent during his first spell at West Ham.
ENGLISH

22. Mauricio Pellegrino Valencia to Liverpool - free 2005. Too advanced in years to offer anything to Liverpool and released after a dozen appearances.
WHITE ARGENTINIAN

21. Louis Saha Fulham to Man United - £12.8m 2004. An injury-hit enigma who has failed to realise his true potential.
BLACK FRENCH

20. DJ Campbell Brentford to Birmingham - £500,000 2006. Signed on the back of FA Cup exploits that were never replicated.
BLACK ENGLISH

19. Ade Akinbiyi Burnley to Sheffield United - £1.75m 2006. Record signing who quickly lost his place and returned to Turf Moor.
NIGERIAN

18. Danny Mills Manchester City to Derby - loan 2008. Signed to add bite to Derby; now out for rest of the season.
ENGLISH

17. Andy Reid Nottingham Forest to Tottenham - £7m (joint fee) 2005. One of many players to disappear in the black hole at Tottenham.
IRISH

16. Scott Parker Charlton to Chelsea - £10m 2004. Wrong club at wrong time. Reignited his stalled career at Newcastle.
ENGLISH

15. Fernando Morientes Monaco to Liverpool - £6.3m 2005. The Spanish striker failed to shine and was soon despatched back home.
SPANISH

14. Jiri Jarosik CSKA Moscow to Chelsea - £2m 2005. Made only a handful of appearances for Jose Mourinho before being loaned out to Birmingham.
CZECH

13. James Beattie Southampton to Everton - £6m 2005. Never a consistent goalscorer at Southampton; things didn't get started at Everton.
ENGLISH

12. Djimi Traore Charlton to Portsmouth - £1m 2007. One of Harry Redknapp's transfer flops has since moved back to France.
MALIAN

11. Rowan Vine Luton to Birmingham - £2.5m 2007. Signed to inspire promotion challenge; failed to impress and has now joined QPR.
ENGLISH

10. Anthony Stokes Arsenal to Sunderland - £2m 2007. Has failed to live up to his reputation at Arsenal and Falkirk.
IRISH

9. Greg Halford Colchester to Reading - £2m 2007. Record signing made just three appearances before leaving for obscurity at Sunderland.
ENGLISH

8. Luis Boa-Morte Fulham to West Ham - £4.5m 2007. A lot of money for a player already past sell-by date.
BLACK PORTUGUESE

7. Michael Ricketts Bolton to Middlesbrough - £2.5m 2003. Won an England cap in 2002, and has been on the slide since.
BLACK ENGLISH

6. Eric Djemba-Djemba Man United to Aston Villa - £1.3m 2005. Alex Ferguson passed on his mistake to Villa; he didn't improve there.
CAMEROONIAN

5. Nigel Quashie Portsmouth to Southampton - £2.1m 2005. Three managers in consecutive seasons thought he was the answer to their troubles. West Brom and Southampton went down, but West Ham survived - after Quashie was dropped.
ANGLO-SCOTTISH MULATTO

4. Nigel Quashie Southampton to West Bromwich - £1.5m 2006.
ANGLO-SCOTTISH MULATTO

3. Nigel Quashie West Bromwich to West Ham - £1.5m 2007.
ANGLO-SCOTTISH MULATTO

2. Matthew Upson Birmingham to West Ham - £7.5m 2007. Lasted a combined 41 minutes in two games last season; improved since.
ENGLISH

1. Jean-Alain Boumsong Rangers to Newcastle - £8m 2005. Accident-prone defender who did much to undermine Graeme Souness' position.
CAMEROONIAN
 
Joined
Jan 9, 2009
Messages
128
I make that:
13 Whites - 52%
12 Non-Whites - 48%

This compares with my recent survey of Premier League players:
Whites 62.6%
Non-Whites 37.3%

Bear in mind that the survey, from a mainstream and politically correct newspaper, covers a period (2003 to 2007) when the number of non-Whites was less than today, and you get an idea of how overrepresented non-Whites are in bad transfer signings.

This strongly suggests that Non-White players are overvalued and White players undervalued.
 

Europe

Mentor
Joined
Oct 26, 2008
Messages
1,642
Why do they have Upson in there?I think he is doing well now, even getting a recent cap.


#24 for 100,000--why did they include that? That was so cheap .you can't expect much.


Jo has got to be one of the worst signings of all time, if you include the summer.
 
Top