Sumo Watch

celticdb15

Hall of Famer
Joined
Jul 24, 2007
Messages
8,469
Agreed Chris, no matter how long their arms they should be able to put up around 25 reps if they really train hard. SMith is 340 and could only put up 225 19 times, thats weak
 

dwid

Hall of Famer
Joined
Feb 17, 2008
Messages
4,254
Location
Louisiana
green fire317 said:
how many black offensive linemen are projected in the first three rounds?
i posted this in another thread but its more suited for here

Leonardfan said:
Anyone else notice that white offensive tackles at the college level get projected to become interior linemen in the nfl?

yes, either that or right tackle, i have a draft guide i bought, waste of money
same garbage written about every player

I will write some of the excerpts of what they wrote. Writing all of the negatives and "the way we see it will take too long, so i will try to some it up.

rated tackles top 20

5. ebon britton 6'6 310: "not a great foot athlete, average lateral quickness. a bit mechanical. Lumbers in space. Not explosive."
"The way we see it: Britton has a skillset better suited for the right side in the pros and may even wind up inside. Does not look pretty but usually gets the job done and possesses day-one starter potential."

So despite having natural strength and being a "solid technicician, very durable and has not missed time to injury, plays hard and competes" "smart and plays with awareness and discipline" he is not rated higher than 4 other tackles and will be moved to the inside, or right side.

8. Troy Kropog Tulane 6'5 316 negatives : "average hip snap -- does not generate much movement" "too lean"
positives: ositives are "good athlete with natural movement skills" "plays smart" "very good work ethic, football is important to him." "good lateral agility" "good blitz recognition"

11. T.J. Lang Eastern Michigan 6'4 305 negatives : "shows some
tightness in his movement
The way we see it : a 3 year starter at LT could wind up being best playing inside."
positives "tough competitor, very good effort and stamina" "good intensity and football temperament." "Physical, has enough agility to handle the edge"

12. Garrett Reynolds 6'7 7/8th 310 negatives :
"Tight-hipped, a bit heavy footed and flat assed"
positives "plays with awareness and adjusts to stunds and blitzes. Flashes some nastiness and finishes blocks." "solid technician. "tough, plays hard with good energy. Good energy and active hands"


"The way we see it: overacheiver will need help to survive on the right side"


19. Alex Boone 6'7 330 Ohio St. negatives:
is on the ground too much. average lateral quickness. exposed by edge speed. lacks discipline. very questionable character- has maturity issues and easily could be distracted by the trappings that come with the NFL. Could struggle to stick on a roster
positives "looks the part with great size, long arms and good growth potential. Good workout numbers. 4 year starter in a big time program"

Wow, a White guy that "looks the part" he has the long arms and is better than the guys going 18 spots ahead of him, it must be his average lateral quickness, oh wait, Michael Oher was said to have that. It must be his maturity issues, wait Andre Smith had that and so did Phil Loadholt. I wonder what else could it be?


Guards (some who have played tackle)

1. Andy Levitre 6'2 3/8th 306 Oregon st, negatives: "lacks ideal arm length to handle the edges and does not play with good extension.
The way we see it: converted left tackle who lackes the size and arm length desired on the outside and projects to the left guard spot."
positives "very smart and has great feel for game. Strong functional athlete. takes good angles. works his hips and maintains positioning. Good base and balance to sustain and finish blocks"
so he has the hip snap but his arm length is hindering him even though it says "plays with very active hands and steers and controls defenders"

3. Kraig Urbik 6'5 323 Wisconsin negatives: "not a great athlete and struggles to handle counters and movement once he turns his shoulders."
positives "can snap his hips and drive defenders off the ball. Flashes explosive power to jolt defenders. Has all the intangibles"
so hes got the "hip snap" and the "explosiveness. but he will still project either the 3rd or 4th round as a guard

9. Andy Kemp 6'5 318 Wisconsin negatives: marginal contact balance, can do a better job sinking his hips.
The way we see it: "A thick, slow-footed mauler with some upside to develop. Shows he can get the job done but doesnt look pretty doing it."
positives: " has good overall size and frame. can get positioning and wall off blockers. Can anchor in pass protection and hold his ground when he bends his knees"

so i guess he projects in the 6th or 7th round as guard because he doesnt look pretty when gets the job done and doesnt have that "hip snap"



11. Ryan Stanchek 6'3 1/8th 305 West Virginia negatives : "does not sink his hips with ease or play with natural bend."
The way we see it: "A good tough, football player who lined up at left tackle in college but projects inside in the pros. Not overly athletic or powerful. Lacks agility to handle edge speed."
positives : "plays with enough agility to pull and trap. A smart player with great awareness and an understanding of blocking angles"
so he projects as a 7th rounder as a backup.

So all of these guys get the job done but "dont look pretty doing it" and they all are not athletic despite dominating in college, have average lateral quickness and some form of problems with "hip snap"

now here are some of the top rated black left tackles

1. Eugene Monroe Virginia 6'5 310 negatives: "uses too much finesse and is not overpowering as a run blocker. Too jumpy anticipating the snap and will open his shoulders and leave the inside susceptible to counter moves. Can punch with more authority and do a better job uncoiling his hands. Not elected a team captain and is not a vocal leader. Durability and mental toughness to play through pain will require further evalauation. but he has 'prototypical size with long arms and looks every bit the part.'"

The number 1 rated left tackle isnt tough physically or mentally! Yes this is the guy i want protecting my quarterbacks left side!

2. Jason Smith Baylor 6'4 305 negatives : "technique is spotty after and will need refining. Could play with more consistent pad level and leverage."
"loaded with upside, excellent athlete"

3. Andre Smith Alabama 6'3 340 negatives : "Weight has fluctuated too often and he tends to balloon in the offseason. Not a foot technician and tends to shuffle and slide instead of kicksliding. Can be late off the ball and tends to get lackadaisical and sloppy with technique. Not a polished protector. Wears down late in games. Questionable makeup to handle distractions that come with the NFL. Questionable character, suspended for sugar bowl against Utah for dealing with an agent."
but they say he has "excellent overall mass with very good hip quickness and agility"

So Andre Smith has questionable character, sloppy, not polished and not disciplined, yet his going slotted at 3 compared to Alex Boone who they said lacked maturity issues and fail to say why they think that he will struggle mentally and is ranked 19.

4. Michael Oher Ole Miss 6'5 305: negatives "Average lateral quickness to slide, shuffle and mirror. Inconsistent hand placement and punch. Technique will need refinement. Looks distinterested at times and can be late to recognize the blitz. Has been coddled throughout college and his desire and passion for the game are iffy. Questionable football intelligence."
but they say "has the physical talent to line up at left tackle"

wait we have a black tackle with average lateral quickness but also doesnt have desire to play the game, but i guess he deserves to be rated higher just because. What a bunch of crap. He must also be rated high because he "looks the part"

7. William Beatty Connecticut negatives 6'6 291 pounds : "plays too soft. Does not have passion for the game. "needs to be challenged". lacks mental toughness. Does not play with power or nastiness. Does not have a mean bone in his body. Not competitive, plays like a cake eating chardonay drinker who does not want to get his finger nails dirty" (thats their analysis not mine)
but they say "he looks the part with a big long armed frame and agility" "extremely athletic"

Yet with all of these negatives hes ranked higher than Troy Kropog whose positives are "good athlete with natural movement skills" "plays smart" "very good work ethic, football is important to him." "good lateral agility" "good blitz recognition"

9. Jamon Merdith South Carolina 6'4 289 pounds "not tough, lacks passion for the game and is motivated for the wrong reasons. Locker-room lawyer" "does not like to condition his body. Too many mental lapses show up in his game. Needs to play with more awareness and do a better job sustaining blocks. Cake-eater, users too much finesse and does not like to get dirty. Does not play with explosion or use his hands with authority, cannot play through pain, lacks mental toughness, was benched as a senior."
but "has good athletic ability

10. Phil Loadholt Oklahoma 6'8 343 pounds, negatives "does not have foot quickness or agility to consitently handle edge speed, struggles to strike a moving target. Not nasty and does not finish blocks the way scouts like. Consistently late into blocks and does not power off the ball or move defenders the way hes expected." "Character needs to be examined with two alcohol related arrests."
but he has "excellent size with long arms"

I cant believe people are getting paid to write this crap. Its just a bunch of garbage

All of these soft guys projected to go in the first or second rounds because they "look the part" and have "upside" despite most of them having no desire to play football

as for how many projected to go in the first 3 rounds
8 tackles, 2 guards, and no centers.

Wow just saw this.
A.Q. Shipley is ranked the 5th best Center but projected to go in the 7th while Edwin Williams is at 6 and projected to go in either the 5th or 6th rounds. WTF?
 

Don Wassall

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Sep 30, 2004
Messages
30,319
Location
Pennsylvania
Nice post, Dwid. You captured the essence of the Caste gibberish designed to cover fortheextremeaffirmative action in football.
 

green fire317

Banned
Joined
Mar 17, 2009
Messages
537
it will be interesting to see how many black offensive linemen will be in the league five years from now.
 

Don Wassall

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Sep 30, 2004
Messages
30,319
Location
Pennsylvania
green fire317 said:
it will be interesting to see how many black offensive linemen will be in the league five years from now.


My guess is probably even more than now. And five years from now they'll still be pushing black QBs as strongly as ever. And there will be even more black coaches, announcers, etc. Nothing will change until enough people are no longer fooled by the whole charade.
 

dwid

Hall of Famer
Joined
Feb 17, 2008
Messages
4,254
Location
Louisiana
Don Wassall said:
Nice post, Dwid. You captured the essence of the Caste gibberish designed to cover for the extreme affirmative action in football.
thanks,
i thought edwin williams being ranked 6 and projected to the 5th or 6th round was bad over number 5 a.q. shipley who projects to go in the 7th
but then they have this guy Antoine Caldwell ranked 8th and he projects to go in the 4th or 5th so im not understanding how this ranking/rating works.

At least Max Unger is ranked number 1 at center and projects to go in the 1st, and the top 5 ranked centers are all White. It seems to be the last White dominated offensive line position.
 

dwid

Hall of Famer
Joined
Feb 17, 2008
Messages
4,254
Location
Louisiana
yeah i dont think many are waking up
id say maybe an extra 2% per year. The higher the player's salaries, the lesser the talent on the field and the worse the economy gets, the more fans will wake up.

Teams are definitely not putting the best players on the field. What I am thinking, from what I have been reading, people are worried about no salary cap for teams coming up. Which means the richest owners will buy the "best" players. This will leave the smaller markets with the option to go with the lesser known White players. There are tons of talented White players who would play for 400,000 (i think that is league min) to a million a year, (it wouldnt matter, most know how to invest their money and not blow it all, so theyd probably wind up with more money than some of the players with huge salaries). There are already guys like that but sit on the bench or get no credit for what they do on the field. A smart coach in a small market could field a majority White team that is very talented for cheap, and i bet they would beat the richer, blacker teams. They would at least be evenly matched.

I don't see why smaller division 1 programs dont do that with players that are very talented but don't get recruited because of their race. Seems like too many of them tend to go with the juco transfers that are usually marginally talented and have had trouble in either academics or the law, or both. They should be putting the best players on the field, regardless of race, and guys that want to play football.

I mean isnt it like this in baseball? no hard cap? and they had the majority White Astros who made it to the World Series.
Edited by: dwid
 

green fire317

Banned
Joined
Mar 17, 2009
Messages
537
I was just watching ESPN and down below it was posting Mel Kiper's and Todd McShay's mock drafts and both of them had Andre Smith going in the top 10. I mean the guy blew up at the combine and has a bad attitude. I just don't get it.
 

dwid

Hall of Famer
Joined
Feb 17, 2008
Messages
4,254
Location
Louisiana
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0878804/

I thought it was bad enough with a book about Michael Oher, now they are making a movie. I hope he becomes a big time bust because he had everything handed to him by some liberal white family and didnt really learn crap from it. Its not like he overcame anything, he still couldnt read. I guess they are going to distort the facts, just like in the book. Guilty Whites who are Ole Miss boosters adopt a black kid who is huge and get him to go to Ole Miss. Barely passes high school with some bogus BYU online courses that the parents helped him with so he could raise his GPA from a .5 or some low number like that. Had his own private tutor, throughout high school and college, and i doubt the classes football players take at Ole Miss these days are that hard.


He hardly learns anything despite being in a better environment and plays for the White family's team. Why didnt the parents adopt any of the other kids in his family? he had like 13 or 14 brothers and sisters, is it because they couldnt play football? hmm...

If he had actually learned something from being in a richer environment then I would give him credit. But the moral of the true story is if you are black, have any sort of hint of athleticism, then things in life are just handed to you.

They are going to make this into a warm fuzzy feel good movie of the year.
 

Deadlift

Hall of Famer
Joined
Aug 2, 2007
Messages
5,240
Location
North Carolina
Jack Lambert said:
If he goes in the Top 10 the stupid team that picks Smith up, I will laugh at them, they just wasted a top 10 pick on this lazy obese loser. If a white man were to be as lazy and out of shape as Smith is, he wouldn't even be signed as a free agent, and they still have him going in the top 10.
smiley11.gif
smiley5.gif


Very true.
 
Joined
Jun 17, 2007
Messages
330
Location
Missouri
I don't wish injury on anyone and I hope he heals up. But you had to see this coming.

Andre Smith fractures foot in first day at practice...


http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/trainingcamp09/news/story?id=4438326




Cincinnati Bengals first-round draft pick Andre Smith just ended his holdout, but now he'll be sitting again.

The offensive lineman fractured his foot during a noncontact drill Tuesday. It is not known how long Smith will be out, but he will miss the Bengals' season opener on Sept. 13. Smith missed 30 days before agreeing to contract terms two days ago.


AFC North blog
ESPN.com's James Walker writes about all things AFC North in his division blog.

"¢ Blog network: NFL Nation


"Andre suffered a small fracture in his left foot during a non-contact drill," Bengals coach Marvin Lewis said in a statement. "Our medical staff tells me the injury will not require surgery. It's too soon to closely predict how long it will be before he can return to practice, but it looks like he's going to miss a few weeks."

Smith is currently on a roster exemption granted by commissioner Roger Goodell because of his late arrival. The exemption lasts until next week.

Smith was the sixth pick in the NFL draft and the most recent to sign. Wide receiver Michael Crabtree of the 49ers is the only unsigned first-round pick.

Sources told ESPN.com's James Walker on Tuesday that the Bengals demanded that Smith have a weight-control clause in his contract. Smith would lose a significant portion of his salary if his weight exceeded 350 pounds.

Though listed at 335 pounds, Smith tipped the scales at 364 when he showed up to sign his contract, convincing team officials to install the clause on the spot, sources told ESPN NFL Insider Adam Schefter.

Smith, whose deal includes $21 million guaranteed and maxes out at six years and $42 million, was trying to claim the starting right tackle job.

If Smith does not get his weight down to 350 pounds in the next 30 days, and he is inactive for a game, the Bengals will have the right to fine him up to 50 percent of one game check (roughly $10,000), sources told Schefter. He would have the chance to recoup the money through performance, but the incentive is there.

Since he resumed football workouts Sunday, Smith's weight already has dropped to 358 pounds, sources said.

Now, the Bengals will keep second-year lineman Anthony Collins at right tackle. Collins was a fourth-round draft pick last year and started six games at right tackle because of injuries.

The line has undergone an overhaul in the offseason. The Bengals made changes at center and at both tackle positions, hoping to upgrade an offense that finished last in the league in 2008.

The priority is protecting quarterback Carson Palmer, who was hit often last year. He broke his nose in the preseason, and tore a ligament and a tendon in his passing elbow during the regular season, forcing him to miss a dozen games.

Palmer suffered a moderate sprain in his left ankle during the first preseason game this year, and has missed the past two. He took snaps with the starting offense on Tuesday for the first time since he got hurt.

"He looked remarkably improved," Lewis said. "He looked pretty good. He was moving better."

Palmer would like to play in the final preseason game, but a source told ESPN NFL Insider Adam Schefter that Palmer will not play in that game. Palmer will play in the regular-season opener, however, the source said.



Senior writer John Clayton covers the NFL for ESPN.com. Information from The Associated Press was used in this report.
 
Joined
Jun 26, 2007
Messages
197
3. Andre Smith Alabama 6'3 340 negatives : "Weight has fluctuated too often and he tends to balloon in the offseason. Not a foot technician and tends to shuffle and slide instead of kicksliding. Can be late off the ball and tends to get lackadaisical and sloppy with technique. Not a polished protector. Wears down late in games. Questionable makeup to handle distractions that come with the NFL. Questionable character, suspended for sugar bowl against Utah for dealing with an agent."
but they say he has "excellent overall mass with very good hip quickness and agility"


damm that hit that nail on the head

az79s5.jpg
Edited by: whiteknight
 

green fire317

Banned
Joined
Mar 17, 2009
Messages
537
the excellent overall mass was my favorite part. everyone here knew an injury with this guy was inevitable. the human foot can only sustain so much weight.
 

dwid

Hall of Famer
Joined
Feb 17, 2008
Messages
4,254
Location
Louisiana
Stats that prove some linemen arent really what they are cracked up to be(mentions some overrated sumos).
he mentions the fact that i have been telling Saints fans that there was no drop off in talent from Brown(black) to Strief (White). It was only the announcer saying there was, constantly. Evans had a bad game which is where the pressure came from.

"B. The Ability of an Offensive Lineman I was watching the usually excellent Cris Collingsworth lamenting in the W15 Saints @ Bears game that the pressure on Brees was far worse because Jamal Brown wasn't in at LT; Zach Strief was starting because Brown was injured. Well during the season Brown gave up pressure on 8% of all passing plays and Strief 5% but in that game 7%. What Collingsworth could have said was the pressure on Brees was worse because the usually excellent Jahri Evans had a poor game but that's not so "obvious"Â￾. Far easier to go with the old standby that the backup isn't up to the standard of the Pro Bowl player whose reputation hasn't diminished despite being awful for the last two seasons. Why? Because Brees doesn't give up sacks even though he's under pressure through his two tackles.

Other players who fall into this category are the hugely overrated Tony Ugoh (whose run blocking deteriorated as well last year) with 3 sacks but 11 hits and 29 pressures. Both of Denver's new tackles picked up rave reviews for their pass blocking based on giving up 0.5 of a sack and 2.5 sacks. The idea of how you give up half a sack aside what this misses is accompanying hits and pressures. Only one tackle gave up more than Ryan Harris's 38 pressures in 2008, you guessed it; Ryan Clady with 39."


Linemen with the best stats according to this, David Stewart who is White.
http://profootballfocus.com/articles.php?tab=articles&arc=&id=7

I dont think his stats are taking into account everything with some teams (like New England's dropoff in line play because of Cassel being new to playing in the league) but he dead on for some of his points.

Id like to see more players broken down to see how White left tackles do compared to black left tackles. Im sick and tired of trying to convince dwf's that Whites are athletic enough to play Left Tackle. I never thought there would be a day when id have to convince someone a White man could play on the Oline.Edited by: dwid
 

Jack Lambert

Hall of Famer
Joined
Jan 3, 2009
Messages
4,743
Speaking of sumos, the Steeler's almost all-sumo O-Line is horrible tonight. Ben will not make it through a season behind them.
 

ToughJ.Riggins

Hall of Famer
Joined
Nov 19, 2006
Messages
5,063
Location
Ontario Canada
dwid said:
"B. The Ability of an Offensive Lineman I was watching the usually excellent Cris Collingsworth lamenting in the W15 Saints @ Bears game that the pressure on Brees was far worse because Jamal Brown wasn't in at LT; Zach Strief was starting because Brown was injured. Well during the season Brown gave up pressure on 8% of all passing plays and Strief 5% but in that game 7%. What Collingsworth could have said was the pressure on Brees was worse because the usually excellent Jahri Evans had a poor game but that's not so "obvious"Â￾. Far easier to go with the old standby that the backup isn't up to the standard of the Pro Bowl player whose reputation hasn't diminished despite being awful for the last two seasons. Why? Because Brees doesn't give up sacks even though he's under pressure through his two tackles.

Other players who fall into this category are the hugely overrated Tony Ugoh (whose run blocking deteriorated as well last year) with 3 sacks but 11 hits and 29 pressures. Both of Denver's new tackles picked up rave reviews for their pass blocking based on giving up 0.5 of a sack and 2.5 sacks. The idea of how you give up half a sack aside what this misses is accompanying hits and pressures. Only one tackle gave up more than Ryan Harris's 38 pressures in 2008, you guessed it; Ryan Clady with 39."

Linemen with the best stats according to this, David Stewart who is White.
http://profootballfocus.com/articles.php?tab=articles&arc=&id=7

This was a great piece of information dwid. Collingsworthless is a buffoon announcer. He's one of the worst in the industry and people like him are the ones that are going to destroy his very own son's (a high prospect at Safety currently playing H.S football) career. I wouldn't be surprised if this clown didn't even object to his own son being called an "overachiever".

I think those stats posted certainly prove that these sumos aren't what they are cracked up to be by the Collingsworthless announcers and dwfs.
 
Top