Dolphins coach Tony Sparano praises Brian Hartline, yet also engages in racial sterotyping, comparing him to Greg Camarillo:
''Brian is a very, very smart guy, along the lines of a Greg Camarillo type,'' Sparano said. ``He's been brought up in the slot -- they used him there a lot at Ohio State. That's maybe his strength.''
Hartline is a track star. How is that white sprinters automatically become "possession" receivers? I'd like to know how this strange loss of speed always seems to occur.
Notice in this article too that Mel Kiper dismisses Hartline as a fourth receiver and special teams demon. At least the Dolphins gave Camarillo an opportunity to play, perhaps the first white receiver since Wayne Chrebt to get such an unexpected promotion, so it appears Hartline landed with the right team, even with his bizarre "loss of speed."
<H1 ="storyline">Miami Dolphins receivers catching on at minicamp</H1>
http://www.miamiherald.com/sports/football/miami-dolphins/st ory/1029804.htmlEdited by: Don Wassall
I think Hartline found the right team too. Considering the only fair teams are the Colts, Pats (when they draft or trade for white talent they use it), Packers (recently), and Texans the odds were stacked against Hartline but I think he will excel down in Florida. Too bad stereotypes persist but atleast he will make his way onto the field.
Camarillo seams screwed to me, but Hartline is probably better anyway. He ran the 60m hurdles at Ohio state and can probably run a 100 in the mid 10's. He's almost as fast as Percy Harvin with the same or better explosiveness.
Mel Kiper's comments on Hartline on draft day were almost disdainful. I'm assuming his comments about Austin Collie were not as bad. After checking one Colts' forum, the fans were generally were unaware of Collie, but were impressed after watching some videos. Naturally, there were resisters in the crowd.
Who the Hell is Mel Kiper?[img]smileys/smiley36.gif[/img]
i hate kiper he is so obnoxious. The reason hartline had a bad season is because Pryor like most black qbs just runs as soon as he recieves the snap. he has no pocket presence at all. Edited by: green fire317
Hartline has just enough speed that he could even play Split-End. He ran a 4.52 at the NFL Combine and has a strong track background in the 300 mtr hurdles. However, the thing that impresses me the most about Hartline is his burst off the line, his agility out of his breaks and his footwork.
I hope Hartline is used as a starter with speed demon (solid, but overrated) Ted Ginn. Camarillo could be a good Slot man (hopefully he's recovered completely from his knee injury). But then guys who are solid black players like Devone Bess and Patrick Turner may complain that Miami has become a white haven for WRs. [img]smileys/smiley11.gif[/img] Edited by: ToughJ.Riggins
i wouldnt be suprised if it was porter who started complaining about too many whites on the team. another loud mouth that i cant stand.
There is no worse athlete than Porter, hes always shooting his mouth off and getting into trouble both on and off the field
I thought you were implying WR Jerry Porter was signed by Miami for a minute- both Jerry and LB- Joey are loud mouths and overrated.
I like Hartline in Miami. This is the same coaching staff, as Don pointed out, that pulled a Wayne Cherbet and gave a starting WR job to an undrafted white player. If I was Hartline I'd just be careful about running a quick slant over the middle in practice because you know a guy like Joey Porter is out to get him.
Also one thing I donnot like is the Dolphins did draft USC WR Patrick Turner the round before Brian.
Hartline is doing very well in the Dolphins training camp, as this blurb indicates. But notice that he is "a very criticized pick around these parts." Why is that? It can't be because of his size because he's 6' 3". It can't be because of his speed because he was a track star. It can't be because he wasn't productive at Ohio State, because he was. Hmmm, I wonder what it could be???
<LI>Brian Hartline - a very criticized pick around these parts - has put together back-to-back great days of practice. He followed up a good day yesterday by making the catch of the day today - a diving TD catch from Chad Henne. He also made a lunging catch from Chad Pennington and caught a deep pass down the middle of the field from Pat White. Right now, Hartline is hot and it doesn't matter which of the three quarterbacks are throwing to him. He's making plays consistently right now. </LI>
http://www.thephinsider.com/2009/8/5...-camp-day-four
Some news about Hartline and Cammarillo.
From Rotoworld:
Greg Camarillo "appears" to have been passed on the depth chart by rookie Brian Hartline, according to beat writer Omar Kelly.
Hartline was the No. 3 receiver in Thursday's practice. It's especially bad news for Camarillo because Hartline has been inconsistent in camp. We suspect Camarillo has had a setback in his surgically repaired knee. Davone Bess' No. 2 job is locked tight.
more news on Brian, also from rotoworld:
Rookie Brian Hartline opened Monday's practice as the Dolphins' first-team flanker.
Either the Fins are trying to motivate Greg Camarillo and Davone Bess, or Hartline's making a serious push to start. He also started Miami's second exhibition, although he caught just one pass for eight yards. Keep an eye on this situation. Camarillo and Bess are now on the second team.
Source: Omar Kelly on Twitter
That is great about Hartline, hopefully, he can start this year. Even if he doesn't start, he should see a lot of time in the slot.
Meanwhile, the coaching staff is not nearly as high on Patrick Turner as the media is.
From Rotoworld:
According to beat writer Armando Salguero, the Dolphins' coaching staff is not nearly as high on rookie wideout Patrick Turner as the media is.
Athletic and 6'5/220, Turner looks excellent on the practice field. But his ability to separate is inconsistent and his desire is questionable. These were the same concerns about Turner during his USC days. He was a monster recruit coming out of high school, but underachieved all four years.
"Davone Bess' No. 2 job is locked tight"
Lol so much for that.Most scouts thought Davone Bess didn't have the measurables to play in the league i believe he ran a 4.7 40? Hedid adecent job playing last year but when a bigger, faster, more talented receiver comes along you would expect him to be moved down on the depth chart. Unless the receiver who is replacing himis white, than it is up for the media to come up for excuses and scrutinize their(white guy)every move!
I watched Bess play at Hawaii with Colt Brennen, and he is a pretty decent WR. He plays alot like a white WR...however, his generic 40 time would have gotten him laughed off the field if he were white.
I think Hartline will get some major playing time this season not only because he's inherently the most athletic, but he's also the only non-smurf (unlike Ginn and Bess). Greg Camarillo is pretty good, but I've heard him speak....he sounds like a total wigger. I'd much rather see Hartline play ahead of him.Edited by: Thrashen
Originally Posted by Thrashen
My thoughts exactly
Apparently Camarillo isn't all the way back from his blown out knee of last season, which is no surprise. Ted Ginn is the number one WR on the Dolphins but he has been a bust so far. I agree that Bess looks to be a competent NFL receiver. Miami's receiving situation will likely continue to be in flux for the rest of training camp and into the season. Hartline has the talent to be a starter, maybe even a star, the question is always what kind of opportunity will he get. But like Austin Collie being drafted by the Colts, he appears to have landed in a good spot. Camarillo starting for the Dolphins last year was the biggest surprise since Wayne Chrebet started as a rookie for the Jets in '95, so at least Tony Sparano has shown he has some fairness for white receivers.
i am glad he is going to have Pennington, an accomplished veteran throwing him the ball
Pennington is a great quarterback but he is injured too often.
Great summary. I think Danny Amendola and Bess are similar players actually. Bess ran a 4.67 40 and Amendola ran a negligibly better 4.64. Both are quick and shifty slot WR types without the element of a good 3rd gear to separate on long fly routes...But we can see who got a chance to start and who very well might be completely done in this league. I am predicting Amendola gets cut from Phili this year.
You might call these two poor men's Wes Welkers as well, but Welker has an absolutely "FREAKISH" first few steps and loses basically ZERO speed when making a move. Welker's absolutely tough as nails and just won't be denied the ball. Welker ran a 4.61/4.65 40 at his Pro Day.
I think either Camarillo or Hartline should play Flanker in Miami and Bess should play the slot as the 3rd wideout.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote